By Toda Namiki, Editor, Japanese Auto World
An electric truck is not a better diesel truck. It trades fuel for battery capacity, and that trade decides the answer. Compare the two on the route you drive, the payload you carry, the charging you can reach and the price you can resell at. Verify each figure against the manufacturer's own specification before you decide.
Key facts
- Diesel holds about 10 percent more energy per gallon than motor gasoline, at 137,380 to 138,490 Btu per gallon for diesel against 124,340 for gasoline, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration.
- A battery adds weight, and that weight reduces the payload a truck can carry within its rated gross vehicle weight.
- Electric truck specifications differ widely between models and generations, so compare the figures for the exact truck.
What decides the comparison?
Four things decide it: the route, the payload, the charging you can reach and the resale market for the truck. A short urban route with a predictable schedule and a depot charger suits an electric truck well. A long route with unreliable charging, or a load close to the payload limit, suits a diesel truck better. Put numbers on each before you choose.
How does battery weight affect payload?
A battery is heavy, and the weight comes out of the payload the truck can carry within its gross vehicle weight rating. Check the payload on the manufacturer's specification for the battery pack you are buying, not for the chassis in general. A truck that carries less than your regular load is the wrong truck, whatever its running costs.
What do running costs depend on?
Running costs depend on the energy price where you operate, the efficiency of the truck on your route, the charging method and the maintenance the truck needs. Diesel brings fuel, filters and exhaust-system work. An electric truck brings battery and charger costs. Work out the cost per mile or kilometre for your route, using local energy prices and the date you collected them.
What is the used-market risk?
A used electric truck's value depends on the battery's health, the warranty status and the supply of replacement packs. Ask for the battery's state of health in writing, and check whether the manufacturer still supports the model. A diesel truck of a common model usually has a deeper parts and workshop base, which matters when you buy used.
What should you verify before you decide?
Verify the gross vehicle weight rating, the payload, the usable range on your route, the charging standard and time, the warranty terms, and the battery health report. Get each figure from the manufacturer or from a dated official source. The used truck buying checklist covers the inspection of a used truck, whichever power source it uses.
Frequently asked questions
Are electric trucks cheaper to run than diesel trucks?
It depends on your route, the energy prices where you operate and how you charge. Work out the cost for your own route rather than relying on a general claim.
Does a diesel truck still make sense?
Often, for long routes, heavy loads or places with limited charging. Compare the two on the route you actually drive.
Verdict
Choose the power source that fits the route and the payload you need, then check the figures for that exact truck. For a first purchase, read the first-time truck buyer guide.